what makes this file such an interesting find, though, is that the shell has been present since at least december 2011
It's really easy to change the creation date of a file by changing the system clock for a millisecond, and create a file, before changing the clock back to normal. Some people like to do this to avoid their back doors being found by IR doing a "find" for any newly created files.
Indeed, that's what `touch -t 201101020304 /tmp/old-file` is for. (Although on ext4 it seems that you can't control the birth time; for that you would need to set your system clock.)