Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The writing of that author you link to nicely matches the description from the other article of the author posted originally (Mark Witton):

http://markwitton-com.blogspot.com/2019/02/how-to-spot-palae...

Mark Witton:

"Another major red flag common to all cranks is their frequent comparison between themselves and scientists who received establishment pushback against their ideas - Wegner, Galileo, Darwin and so on."

The article you posted:

"It is admirable how the persistent efforts of a handful of Wegener’s converts were able to overcome the arrogance of the majority." ... "This present article is having a somewhat similar history."

Mark Witton:

"Saving the best until last: yes, unbelievable as it is, there are individuals who suggest mainstream scientists are somehow organising against them to suppress their work. While maybe not imagining something as sinister as the Big Pharma conspiracy, some cranks infer that palaeontology is governed by individuals who dictate what is and what isn't acceptable science, and who forbid the publication of work that challenges the status quo."

The article you posted:

"This paper in its various versions has had a battered history. Here are the journals that were sent this paper and either returned it unread or just discarded it." "It seems that this paper is too radical for today’s journals."

By the way, the article from your link is not by the guy who posted the copy of it on his blog, but by a much older chemist:

https://issuu.com/pedrott600re/docs/levenspiel.com_octave_ol...



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: