Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | sammy2255's commentslogin


Germany banning books.. sounds awfully familiar

"Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


Not every comment about Germany requires a mention of a dark past.

Doesn't require it, but in this case it sure is relevant

It does not, since the context is absolutely not the same. Closing a major piracy actor VS actions that led to a world war.

Banning books is the same as banning books. Whether it's in the name of censorship or anti-piracy

Not sure you can call it censorship if it's the author of the book who doesn't want you to access it for free. I know there are a few levels of indirection here, but with a few notable exceptions authors are normally against their books being pirated.

I personally sure want Anna's Archive staying up, but comparing it to nazis burning books is a bit too much IMO


Because the US doesn't act against copyright infringement? They just suspended the Annas Archive .org domain

At least we don't ban books from Libraries, because they contain the true history or "wrong thought" and Republicans don't like that


This isn't banning books, it's akin to banning a book store. If a book store chain isn't paying their taxes and gets shut down, the books have not been banned or censored.

Don't even need to rely to anti-piracy to find book banners. US public schools continue to accelerate their book banning tendencies.

* https://pen.org/banned-books-list-2025/ * https://www.ala.org/news/2025/04/american-library-associatio... * https://cdhe.colorado.gov/banned-book-list

Book bans at department of defense high schools are resulting directly from this administration's executive orders.

* https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/dodea-book-bans

We need to keep fighting for the right to read freely.

Meanwhile, waiting for Cloudflare to walk away from their US government contracts to protest these blatant free speech attacks.


I mean when Germany is jailing people for being "offensive" it's hard not too.

You are confidently incorrect, very impressive.

Don't worry, this time it's the Social Democrats who ban books, it's _totally_ different.

Most western countries who care about IP have banned piracy. I'm not anti piracy but it's silly to compare.

Back in the day it was US media companies which started the big war against piracy and for the use of DRM. It was pushed by US media companies and the US government upon Europe. Same as with software patents. It's weird that now US companies complain about local media rights holders doing their censorship thing when the whole thing was started by the US.

I'm not sure, does US not block websites by DNS? Wrt Anna's Archive they've gone as far as revoking its main domain

US owns the registrars, they just deregister domains they don't like and show some sort of FBI logo instead.

I demand the RIGHT to get media for free without paying for it! And I equate this with a ban on literature!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_banning_in_the_United_Sta...

> Participants: Republican lawmakers in red states

oh weird, it's the opposite of what you said.


Politics isn't the exclusive hobby of the united states.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_democracy

https://www.deutschland.de/en/topic/politics/the-spd-parties...

And by the way, in the same wikipedia link you posted, there's documentation of Democrats also banning books.


What book banning are you referencing, then? it's all very vague

I can buy all the books listed there in the USA.

That's privilege. They're not available at the library at the learning centers.

*learing centers

Now I understand you live in a skewed world view

So should we stop being cynical and start writing "You're absolutely right!"

Critique is not necessarily a bad thing, and the author doesn't advocate for any change. It's just an observation. There is such a thing as toxic positivity as well, and if I'm not mistaken there's even a setting for the tone in ChatGPT to get rid of it.

Why do you say that? Curl (arguably one of the most used open source software in the world) currently has 5 open issues https://github.com/curl/curl/issues


Not sure curl is a good example since it’s already very mature and boring (in a good way)


Is this article written by a child?

"he grew Berkshire from a struggling New England textile mill that he starting buying up for $7.60 a share in 1962"


Probably an Indian


"in today's fast paced business environment ... "

- our prolific overseas medium.com bloggers


Doesn't it differ by aircraft too? I believe the 787 dreamliner has a UV water purification system for potable water.


Why did you write your comment with ChatGPT?


@grok is this true?


They had me until they hit me with their "It's not just poop; it's fart." writing style


I don't understand how this is possible. I've heard the New York Subway system is riddled with antisocial behaviour, homeless, drunks, people pissing everywhere, etc.


People say the same thing about BART but it’s not bad at all. Turns out people on the internet aren’t reliable.


They've already proved themselves as competent. $50k a year to a billion dollar company is nothing. Even if they find 0 vulnerabilities a year it's still worth it to them


I directionally agree with you but we could go another 20 comments deep on exactly what the purpose of an external pentest or red-team exercise is and how it might not match up perfectly with what an amateur web hacker is currently doing. But like: yeah, they could get into that business, at least until AI eats it.


So now they found a vulnerability, the company should pay them $50k a year until they retire because they proved themselves competent?


Yes?


You should add a graph of visitors per-minute for the status page for the past 24 hours or so. Would really help for situations like this


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: